Where to buy red worms in Indiana

Estimated reading time: 6 minutes

Want to buy worms in Indiana? You’re in luck!

In today’s post, I will share a few ways you can get started with vermicomposting or starting your worm farm. I’ll share resources that are within the Indiana state boundaries. Ideally, I want to provide local resources so you can support someone within your community. Of course, you could always purchase worms from our friends over at Meme’s Worms (clicking this link helps keep the website, thanks in advance!).

Let’s jump in.

Where To Buy Worms In Indiana

Contact Fishing And Tackle Stores

First, let’s start by discussing one of the most common places in IL to buy compost worms – the bait shop. Many visit their local bait shop looking for earthworm worms to catch fish. However, many bait shops also carry red and blue worms, which are great for composting.

Before you stop by your local bait shop, call ahead and ask if they carry red wigglers. They are also known as Eisenia fetida, tiger, or red worms. These are all names for the same worm, our friendly compost worm. Another variety that you can use is the blue worm.

Dig In The Dirt (The Free Method)

You can dig for your worms if you don’t have much money or want a family-friendly activity. After significant rainfall, dig around the leaf litter in your backyard or park. Worms will go to the surface after rain to breathe. You will not need to search very far to find a lot of worms.

You can also find composting worms in the leaf litter in the woods, manure piles, or outdoor compost piles.

This is one of my favorite methods because:

  1. You use native worms (releasable back in nature)
  2. It’s free
  3. Fun and kid-friendly
  4. Harms fewer worms in the process
  5. Includes beneficial bacteria to help your worms get established
Indiana vermicomposting buy worms
Indiana has a wide variety of mountains, lakes, and streams

This method is beneficial for people who are looking for a slow start. If you find just 25-50 worms, it will take six months to build a population of 205+ worms. Worms create cocoons that can release 3-5 worms every 90 days.

If you are okay with a slow start to vermicomposting, this is a great and fun way to get started.

Check Farm And Garden Supply Businesses

Finally, the local farm and garden store is one of the last places you could check in your town.

Next, stores that recently started carrying compost worms are farm supplies, garden stores, and plant nurseries. As research about the benefits of soil biodiversity, more people are looking to compost. They also release red worms into the soil to boost the soil quality permanently.

For this reason, more stores carry worms for purchase. It is essential to call ahead to check that they have worms, not worm castings. Worm castings are the same as vermicompost or the nutrient-rich poop of your worms.

Local Online Sellers

Social Media Marketplaces

If you were unsuccessful at the bait shop or the garden store and didn’t want to dig for worms, you can always check online. You can support local worm sellers by checking social media profiles. Websites like Facebook, Reddit, Pinterest, or other social media platforms have marketplaces or groups dedicated to vermicomposting and worm farming.

I could get my start in apartment composting through a social media marketplace. I put a message to trade a bag of premium coffee for a container of compost worms. A letter from a local composter arrived in my inbox in a few hours. She said I could come to grab a few shovels full of her outdoor compost pile.

I stopped by to grab a large yogurt container full of worms. We spoke for nearly an hour about our passion for vermicomposting and gardening.

This is an excellent option because you can share the joy of composting and meet someone in your community—a win-win.

Buy Worms In IN On Craigslist, eBay, and Etsy Sellers

One place I forgot about when I got started was Craigslist. I remember checking this site whenever I want to sell a car or buy a bicycle. I didn’t think about it as a place to buy composting worms. You’d be surprised how many people sell composting worms and vermicompost for extra money.

This is a great way to support a local seller. Here are some quick links to buy worms in Indiana on Craigslist.

Beyond Craigslist, you can search for worms on eBay and Etsy. Both of these online marketplaces allow you to explore their listings by location. Filter the search results based on your site. Below I’ve circled the area where you can find this feature on eBay. If you can’t find any sellers within 25 miles, you can increase the search radius until you find a seller.

Composting worms Ebay
Add your zip code to find sellers near you

Click here to check eBay

Click here to check Etsy

Worm Stores In Indiana

Thankfully, if you want to purchase worms from a worm breeder in Indiana, you have some options. Below I’ve listed a few different places you can find worms. These also include some home and garden stores that sell worms as well. If you know a brick-and-mortar business where you can buy worms, please share their information below!

Indiana Compost worms

I found one store where you can buy African Night Crawlers.

102 Williams St.
Michigan City, IN 46360
(219) 379-4749

Add a website

If you know of other websites to directly buy red worms in Indiana, please share them below. Our goal is to make it easier for vermicomposters to get started.